As parents, teachers, and caregivers, our words hold immense power. They shape how children see themselves, their behavior, and even their long-term self-esteem. But how often do we unknowingly use labels like “good” or “bad” to describe their actions? While seemingly harmless, these labels can have a profound impact on how children perceive themselves and their place in the world.
This blog explores why labeling children as “good” or “bad” is problematic, the long-term effects it can have on their sense of self, and actionable strategies to guide behavior in a more constructive way.
The Problem with Labels Like “Good” or “Bad”
It’s natural to want to express your frustration when your child misbehaves or celebrate when they follow instructions. But when we use terms like “bad boy,” “good girl,” or even “you’re being bad,” we unintentionally tie their worth to their behavior.
Labels like these can shape how children view themselves:
- Internalizing Negative Labels: When kids are told they’re “bad,” they may start to believe it’s a fixed part of who they are. This can lead to a cycle of poor choices and low self-esteem.
- Overdependence on Praise: Conversely, labeling children as “good” all the time can create pressure to seek external validation. They may start associating their value with constant approval rather than their own internal sense of right and wrong.
As a martial arts instructor, I’ve worked with kids as young as two or three who have already started calling themselves “bad.” When I hear those words, I stop everything to remind them of the truth: they are not bad—they’re simply learning, growing, and figuring out how to make better choices.
Why “Good” and “Bad” Labels Stick with Children
The words we use with children are like seeds planted in their minds, growing into beliefs over time. Research shows that children develop their self-concept—their understanding of who they are—based largely on feedback from the adults around them.
When we label behavior as “good” or “bad,” kids may:
- Link Self-Worth to Behavior: Instead of seeing mistakes as opportunities to grow, they begin to think their actions define their character.
- Feel Trapped in Labels: A child repeatedly labeled “bad” may feel incapable of change, while one constantly called “good” might fear making mistakes.
- Lose Motivation: If praise isn’t balanced or feels unattainable, kids may stop trying altogether, thinking, “What’s the point?”
Focus on the Behavior, Not the Child
One of the most effective ways to guide children is by separating who they are from what they do. Behavior is fluid—it can change and improve—but a child’s worth should never be questioned.
Here’s how to do it:
- Shift the Language: Instead of saying, “You’re bad for not listening,” try, “Not listening wasn’t the best choice. Let’s talk about what we can do next time.”
- Be Specific: Highlight the behavior, not their character. For example, “Throwing your toys hurt your brother’s feelings. Let’s find a way to play together nicely.”
When children hear that their behavior is something they can change, they feel empowered to make better choices without internalizing negativity.
The Power of Specific Praise and Feedback
Generic praise like “Good job” feels nice in the moment but doesn’t give kids much to build on. Instead, focus on specific feedback that highlights effort, growth, or positive choices.
- Examples of Specific Praise:
- “You worked really hard to finish that puzzle. I love how you didn’t give up!”
- “Thank you for sharing your toys with your sister. That was so kind.”
- Avoid Empty Praise: Instead of saying, “You’re so smart,” try, “You did a great job figuring out that tough math problem!”
By focusing on effort and improvement, you teach children that their abilities and character can grow with time and dedication.
Teaching Kids to Make Better Choices
Sometimes, kids need more than feedback—they need tools to handle tough situations and make better choices in the future.
- Teach Emotional Regulation: Help kids identify their emotions and practice calming techniques, like deep breathing or taking a short break when they feel overwhelmed.
- Encourage Problem-Solving: Instead of stepping in to fix everything, ask questions that guide them to solutions. For instance, “What do you think you could do differently next time?”
- Give Them Clear Steps: When correcting behavior, offer actionable advice. For example, “Next time, remember to raise your hand before speaking in class.”
A Real-Life Example from Martial Arts
In my martial arts classes, I use a reward system where kids can earn prizes for listening, trying their best, and following directions. Sometimes, a child doesn’t meet the expectations for earning a prize. When this happens, I never say, “You didn’t get a prize because you were bad.” Instead, I explain:
- What went well: “I loved how you helped put the mats away.”
- What they can improve: “Next time, we need to focus on listening during the warm-up.”
This approach reinforces that their worth isn’t tied to a reward—it’s tied to their effort and growth.
Building a Positive Sense of Self
When we move away from labels like “good” or “bad,” we create space for children to see themselves as capable, resilient, and worthy—no matter what. Mistakes become opportunities to learn rather than proof of inadequacy.
- Encourage a Growth Mindset: Help kids see challenges as a chance to grow. Remind them that effort matters more than perfection.
- Model the Behavior You Want: Show patience, kindness, and the willingness to learn from your own mistakes. Kids learn more from what you do than what you say.
- Celebrate Progress: Focus on how far they’ve come rather than how far they still need to go.
Conclusion: Words That Empower, Not Limit
Parenting and teaching are about guiding children to become their best selves—not by labeling them, but by nurturing their potential. The words we choose can either limit them or inspire them to grow.
So the next time you’re tempted to say, “You’re such a good kid,” or “Why are you being bad?” pause and reframe. Focus on their behavior, offer encouragement, and equip them with tools to succeed.
When we empower children to see themselves as capable of growth and change, we give them the confidence to thrive—not just in childhood, but throughout their lives.
Struggling with parenting challenges? Don’t go it alone. Book your family strategy call now at call.familymaa.com to gain expert guidance and actionable strategies that work for your family.